reading
I didn't bring much good reading with me, so the only books I've read recently are those that magically appear in the harp practice room (Dan Brown's Angels and Demons, Terry Pratchett's Thief of Time - on the lighter side). One of my wonderful cabitory-dudes gave me a much needed heavier book of short stories by JD Salinger. (This might explain the random post about the clapping koan. Definitely doesn't explain the llamas, though.) My first assignment was to read Teddy.
Teddy is a well-written story, but not everyone will find it enjoyable. (By the way, if you don't want to be influenced by my thoughts on it before you actually read it, stop now. My discussion may also ruin the ending.) The story itself as a vehicle for Salinger's philosophy is very thought-provoking on many levels, although it can be depressing (I've heard). Subsequent readings are a must, and incredibly exciting, as they reveal seemingly limitless foreshadowing.
I do not feel that this story is depressing, because I think Salinger prepares the reader to see the ending as natural and inevitable rather than a tragedy. According to Teddy's outlook, the ending is déjà vu and most likely has a positive result. Actually, Teddy's philosophy is the underpinning for my view of the ending as happy, because it can only be that way from his perspective. Salinger's portrayal of Teddy's family life almost makes the ending a relief, as his parents have incredible conflict and repeatedly reject his attempts to communicate something very important at the beginning. With Teddy's perspective, the ending is his escape from their conflict and his unspiritual American life. All the foreshadowing, and especially Teddy's foreshadowing, prevents the ending from being a shock. Getting Teddy's detailed commentary before the event is fascinating, as this is usually not possible in this situation. It definitely helps create the feeling of inevitability combined with naturalness, even though the ending is still quite dramatic. Salinger uses everything in this story to enhance the reader's understanding of the philosophy by letting them live it with Teddy - for a day.
This story raises so many questions. What do you think of Teddy's philosophy? How would you act, if you were Teddy? Was this a homicide, or a suicide? What happened to Booper?
Why did Nicholson smoke his cigarette? smoking is bad.
Teddy is a well-written story, but not everyone will find it enjoyable. (By the way, if you don't want to be influenced by my thoughts on it before you actually read it, stop now. My discussion may also ruin the ending.) The story itself as a vehicle for Salinger's philosophy is very thought-provoking on many levels, although it can be depressing (I've heard). Subsequent readings are a must, and incredibly exciting, as they reveal seemingly limitless foreshadowing.
I do not feel that this story is depressing, because I think Salinger prepares the reader to see the ending as natural and inevitable rather than a tragedy. According to Teddy's outlook, the ending is déjà vu and most likely has a positive result. Actually, Teddy's philosophy is the underpinning for my view of the ending as happy, because it can only be that way from his perspective. Salinger's portrayal of Teddy's family life almost makes the ending a relief, as his parents have incredible conflict and repeatedly reject his attempts to communicate something very important at the beginning. With Teddy's perspective, the ending is his escape from their conflict and his unspiritual American life. All the foreshadowing, and especially Teddy's foreshadowing, prevents the ending from being a shock. Getting Teddy's detailed commentary before the event is fascinating, as this is usually not possible in this situation. It definitely helps create the feeling of inevitability combined with naturalness, even though the ending is still quite dramatic. Salinger uses everything in this story to enhance the reader's understanding of the philosophy by letting them live it with Teddy - for a day.
This story raises so many questions. What do you think of Teddy's philosophy? How would you act, if you were Teddy? Was this a homicide, or a suicide? What happened to Booper?
Why did Nicholson smoke his cigarette? smoking is bad.
